I'm not keen on her either, but still, messa must know. xD
It could do. I may just have to start up a game with her character and see. Thought I'd see if anyone knew off the top of their head though, especially if it plays elsewhere than her initial storyline.
I play Carlie and she's one of my favorites. I'm playing her right now in SD3. My point is--I don't have the CD you're mentioning but if you could put the song up, I could take a listen and tell you if it rings any bells.
Carlie would be mt least favorite character in SD3, but yes, I think that they play her song at the beginning of her story. When you find her in the waterfall, it plays Athena's song. These brings some else in mind though, in Duran's beginning, why is there Rolante's theme during the swordsmanship competion?